assumed that in this demand the people are rejecting the theocratic ideal. After all, does not Yahweh himself say that they have rejected me as their king (v. 7)? Another view is that they are rejecting what we might call the charismatic ideal, namely, rule by judges whom God raises up as needed and bestows on them the ‘charism’ (gifting) to lead in times of crisis. After all, the ‘judge’ Samuel feels rejected (v. 6). What the elders explicitly say is that they want to be like their neighbours (kĕkol-haggôyim,
Page 104